This stuff is legit. It has all the yummy properties of cheese with none of the stomachache :D
{Pin this}
Look at it! Just sitting here looking at it makes me want to gobble gobble gobble.
I also submitted this to allergy free wednesdays! Make sure to check it out there! UPDATE: This has been featured by the lovely Tessa the Domestica Diva over on allergy-free wednesdays!
Now vegans or lactose or casein intolerant people can have their cheese AND ENJOY it!
This is a doubled recipe. You can feel free to halve it with great results. I like it doubled because then during the week, I can make macaroni and cheese, melted tuna sandwiches, grilled cheese polenta, and so on and so farth. You make ask tuna? Alas, I'm not vegan. At least half of my recipes are so make sure to check the kitchenette link above. Big Blue Eyes and I are highly sensitive to dairy and have eliminated it from our lifestyle. I do admire those who eat a vegan lifestyle and because we eat only sustainable, farm-grown meat or wild game, we also eat a lot of vegetarian meals which minus the dairy and eggs equals vegan.
{Pin this}
Remember this? This stems from that recipe, which was more of a coconut milk mozzarella.
These are also gluten-free because we used brown rice tortillas from Trader Joe's. You can feel free to use corn tortillas! I also used white balsamic vinegar from Trader Joe's. I have used no other kind of vinegar so I can't vouch for their taste. However Erin from Olives from Dinner uses coconut vnegar. You can order agar flakes from amazon or azure standard.
{Pin this}
Coconut Milk Cheddar (UPDATED)Ingredients:
2 cans coconut milk (full fat, thai kitchen brand prefered)
3 T agar flakes *(see notes below if using agar powder)
1 t white balsamic vinegar
4 T tapioca starch
1 t smoked paprika
1/4 t liquid smoke
2 t sea salt
1/4 c nutritional yeast flakes (optional but definitely gives it more cheesy-ness) - UPDATE
Pinch of turmeric (for more authentic cheese color - optional)
1. Boil coconut milk until no longer seperated. Add white balsamic vinegar, agar flakes, and salt. Boil gently for 15. * (no need to boil 15 minutes if using agar agar powder)
2. Add remaining ingredients, one at a time. Whisking all the while! Cook another 5-10 minutes.
3. Remove from pan and put in greased, flat-bottomed glass dish or parchment paper lined loaf pan.
4. Let cool two hours. You can also stick in fridge when cool and use the next day. Slice and enjoy! (If it's refridgerated, you can actually grate it. It's a little slippery though and easier to just slice).
*UPDATE (please read): Agar agar powder speeds this wonderful process of vegan cheese-making. With the agar agar powder, you don't have to boil it nearly as long. Use only three teaspoons with the powder. After you add the vinegar, agar agar powder and salt to the milk mixture, let it get a good boil then add all the remaining ingredients one by one whisking all the while. Remove from heat and Place in container.
For quesadillas, add coconut oil to pan and warm the quesadilla while layering slices of cheese one half, fold over when tortilla is warm enough to move easily. Cook on both sides to get a crispy and delicious texture! The cheese willl melt perfectly!










So excited to try this! I will be featuring your recipe this week on Allergy Free Wednesday!
ReplyDeleteThank you! I am so honored!
DeleteIt's my first feature on allergy-free wednesday! Yay!
Thank you
Mary
Mind if i ask what makes this taste cheesy? I don't have liquid smoke, but will buy it to make this and other stuff...
ReplyDeleteI've updated it to include nutritional yeast which with that combined with the smoked paprika gives a cheddar cheesy taste.
DeleteHowever it really is the full-fat coconut milk that allows it to be so meltable and delicious.
In this recipe I don't use liquid smoke either - http://sweetroots.blogspot.com/2012/06/vegan-quesadillas-homemade-coconut-milk.html
You don't necessarily need the liquid smoke. It just adds a real depth to the cheese that you wouldn't normally get.
Thanks
Hope this helps!
Mary
Perfect! Thanks for this response! We don't have 'liquid smoke' here in Australia, and I see it included in recipes all the time. Wondered if it would work with out it! So keen to try!
DeleteHi! This looks amazing! Can I ask if there is a healthy liquid smoke option?
ReplyDeleteThere is a liquid smoke made by burning rice hulls instead of hickory. I can't seem to find where that is sold.
DeleteYou can also omit this if you like and perhaps add some extra smoked paprika and nutritional yeast. I hope this helps!
In my coconut milk mozzarella, I don't add any liquid smoke and it is just as delicious. REcipe here http://sweetroots.blogspot.com/2012/06/vegan-quesadillas-homemade-coconut-milk.html
Thanks
Mary
I have agar agar powder. will that work instead of flakes?
ReplyDeleteHi Joy,
DeleteI have not used agar agar powder but I had put it on my list of things to try. Supposedly one teaspoon of powder equals one tablespoon flakes. Let me know how that works for you!
Thanks
Mary
It's updated with instructions on using agar agar powder.
DeleteIf using agar powder should it still be 3 Tablespoons or should it just be 3 Teaspoons?
DeleteThanks!
Oh goodness! The update was not clear about that. Thank you for pointing that out. It is supposed to be 3 teaspoons for agar agar powder.
DeleteOkay, okay ~ I give! I'll try agar agar flakes! lol For years and years I've kept the notion that it was too pricey to use and have skipped over recipes using it. However, your delectable-looking recipe has made me re-evaluate its cost. It can't be pricier than the vegan cheeses on the market these days! And I adore anything using coconut milk....
ReplyDeleteIf you compared the size of your finished block of cheese to an 8-10 oz. package of vegan cheese from the market, how would it compare in your opinion?
Ha ha I know! Agar agar flakes are not the cheapest thing on the market. But this is definitely worth it!
DeleteNow that you've said this I wish I had weighed it! I will weigh it again next time I make it. It's not as dense as regular cheddar block on the market but roughly same size.
Agar Agar flakes and powder are cheap at your local asian foods market. i get 2 packs of powder which is roughtly the same amount as as a gox of gelatine for $2.38 at one asain foods store at the ther it is 2.78. Also the canned coconut milk is much cheaper (2.39/can for A Taste of Thai) and if buying ARROY-D brand ($1.49/can )of a much better quality the Thai Kitchen with far fewer additives. As a matter of fact the only ingerdients are coconut and milk, it doesn't even have guar gum! How cool is that?
DeleteWe are also gluten free and my starches and white rice flour are much much cheaper at the asiain markets ( between .77/lb and .89/lb)
Thank Kendra for that info!
DeleteI so need to travel to the next town so I can go all crazy on the asian market there.
I am making the cheese this morning. Instead of the balsamic vinegar, I used apple cider vinegar (just because I had it). I didn't have quite enough agar flakes to make 3T....it was more like 2.5 T, but we will see how it turns out.
ReplyDeleteI poured the mixture into the parchment lined pan and noticed that some of the mixture was on the liquid side vs. cheesy side. Is this normal? Or should it have all blended together better?
I am planning to use this for lunch today...either in a buckwheat pizza crust or maybe some quinoa mac 'n cheese? The true test will be what the kids think...I'll keep you posted.
Thanks so much for the recipe.....I imagine this is going to taste closer to cheese than any other vegan cheeses I made before. We've never been able to do cashew cheese because my daughter has a severe nut allergy.
Jennie
The cheese mixture will seem liquidy at first but will set at room temperature after an hour (or sooner).
DeleteLet me know how 2.5 T works out for the cheese setting. The vinegar deactivates the agar setting a little so you can also halve the vinegar if you don't have enough agar although I've never done this and can't perdict exact results.
I'm glad this is something your daughter can eat! Let me know how this works out for you!
This looks so amazing- such good, clean ingredients, unlike many of the store bought brands. Wow- I am so excited to try this :)
ReplyDeleteYes, most of the ingredients are nutritious. Say yes to healthy fats! And of course nutritional yeast for all the great B vitamins!
Deletethe cheddar looks so good! awesome creation!
ReplyDeleteI made this today, and it tasted very good in a quesadilla. I used agar powder instead of flakes (1 tsp. in place of 1 Tbsp.), and it came out squishy, more like a spreadable cheese than a cheese that you grate. But that just made it easy to smooth onto the tortilla :o) Thanks for the great recipe!
ReplyDeleteThanks for letting me know!
DeleteI am glad you enjoyed it!
I made this a couple days ago, also with agar powder instead of flakes, but the texture came out spot on. The texture of this is better than any vegan cheese I've made, so that's awesome. However much I love coconut, the taste of the coconut milk was a bit too weird for me in the cheese, so next time I'm going to try it with soy cream and I bet it will come out perfect for me!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the info!
DeleteI'm wondering what brand of coconut milk you used?
Let me know how your soy cheese tastes like. I've had plans to try it with my rice creamer but not sure how it will melt since it doesn't have a lot of fat.
This sounds so yummy. I am allergic to vinegar & yeast. Can I substitute lemon juice for the vinegar? Is there anything I can substitute for the yeast?
ReplyDeleteI haven't had cheese in over a year, due to allergies, I miss it so.
Have you checked out my mozzarella recipe? It uses considerably less nutritional yeast and I've even omitted it once because I had none in my pantry. I would just omit the nutritional yeast completely. The mixture might not be as firm but you can add a tablespoon of arrowroot or tapioca powder to fix that. You can always try adding just a little more smoked paprika and powdered garlic.
DeleteDefinitely try the lemon juice! The vinegar helps to break down the agar a little bit and the acid from the lemon juice would work just as well.
Let me know how this works for you!
How big is a can of coconut milk? The ones here are all about 400ml, and using two of them produced a wobbly gelatinous mess that looked more like a breast implant than cheese... tasted good, though.
ReplyDeleteI'm totally loving the way you described your cheese.
DeleteThe coconut milk I use is 400ml or about 1.5 cups. I'm not sure why yours turned out so gelatinous. You can try cutting the vinegar in half so the agar agar doesn't break down as much.
Hope that helps!
I have some coconut milk that needs to get used up. I am trying this immediately!
ReplyDeleteHi Mary,
ReplyDeleteI'm newly vegan (about 6 weeks) and was anxious to try your cheese. The photos are beautiful! I only made half a recipe in case it didn't turn out. (oh me of little faith) Also, there are only two of us to eat it anyway. I couldn't find white basalmic vinegar and used rice vinegar instead. Also substituted agar powder for the flakes. (I used 1 1/2 tsp for the half recipe) I used the Thai Kitchen coconut milk. It was looking very nice and creamy until I added the tapioca starch, yeast flakes and paprika. Then the oil separated from the rest of it and couldn't get it to incorporate again. I even used an electric vertical stick blender! I poured it into the bowl and it is cooling right now. The oil is floating to the top though. What did I do wrong? Any suggestions? Thanks.
My first thought is how old is the coconut milk can? Does it have an expiration date on it?
DeleteI'm sorry this happened. How disappointing! I've never had anything like this happen (yet). I will research and see if I can find anything.
Hi Mary,
DeleteThanks for your reply. I just bought it a couple of days ago. It says "Good until Dec 3, 2013." I sure hope you can help me find a way to make this work. Yours looks wonderful!
We will get to the bottom of this!
DeleteI think I found the problem. For agar powder, it doesn't need to cook as long.
DeleteJust bring the coconut milk and agar powder with vinegar and salt to a good boil then add remaining ingredients, one at a time while whisking. Remove from heat.
So sorry about the confusion. I had used agar flakes in the past but today used agar agar powder and if you boil it longer than five minutes with the powder, the coconut milk can seperate.
Hope this helps!
Awesome! I will definitely give it a try with your new directions. Also..I've been searching all over for smoked paprika and white basalmic vinegar, and finally found them both at Trader Joes. Thank you so much for working on this for all of us!
DeleteI probably won't be able to try this till sometime next week, but I'll let you know how it turns out. Thanks Mary!
DeleteHoly cow those quesadillas look lovely ... awesome photos as usual!
ReplyDeleteWow...this is so creative and I want to try it now! I found this when I was looking at your post for Iced coconut chai on Wellness Weekend! I would love for you to link this up to my blog party, Healthy Vegan Fridays. You can check out this week's here: http://everydayvegangirl.blogspot.com/2012/08/healthy-vegan-fridays-3.html
ReplyDeleteOh my gosh! Awesome recipe! I just made this and am licking the pot clean. It is delicious!
ReplyDeleteI made this and loved it! Blogged about it today - thank you so much for sharing this amazing recipe!
ReplyDeleteWow! This looks amazing and I am jealous of those brown rice tortillas!
ReplyDeleteI am absolutely thrilled to find this awesome recipe! Subscribing!
ReplyDeleteOh my - trader joe's brown rice tortillas? My tj's told me over a year ago they were discontinued. I might just have to look into that again.
ReplyDeleteYour quesadillas are gorgeous and I can't wait to try that cheese.
I messed about with this recipe a bit. I used 2 cans of coconut cream (not milk) which is creamier and much thicker. I added 2tsp of prepared yellow American Mustard and upped the vinegar to 2 tsp total. I added 2 tsp white miso for that umami cheezy goodness taste and as I only had powdered agar I used that. I checked online and apparently 1tsp agar powder = 1 tbs agar flakes. I used this translation BUT my cheeze didn't set up well. It has the texture of brie and so I will use 4tsp of agar powder next time to be sure BUT the cheeze is amazing! Its like a gooey brie/camenbert and tastes just heavenly! I recommend adding the mustard and the miso because they add so much to the flavour. Next time I am going to add some pureed grilled capsicum for colour and more flavour. I LOVE this recipe! No more going into debt to buy nuts when you can use coconut cream. So simple, so delicious and so achievable! Cheers for this wonderful foundation recipe. I will mess about with this more. How about Mixing in some pesto to half of the mix and pouring it in even layers? How about using some sundried tomatoes (pureed) to give more flavour? Or some pink peppercorns in brine? So many different flavours to try and all gooey and unctious! I can see this cheeze being eaten before I get to try it in a recipe but it promises to be something amazing once cooked. :)
ReplyDeleteI am so glad you liked this recipe! It does have so many possibilities!
DeleteMiso is a great additive! I wanted to create a recipe that is soy-free for my readers who can't eat soy (but I do love my miso).
I'm glad you liked it and would love to hear all your wonderful variations!
Any idea if this can be frozen? Or how long is it ok in the fridge...? Thanks :) I just made two med cheese rounds and i have a tiny one left over in a ramekin to take to a friends place tomorrow!
ReplyDeleteWould love to make this for my son but I am out of tapioca starch any other substitutions? I am also out of potato starch and arrowroot if you were going to suggest those.
ReplyDeleteAnd cornstarch? You could try using a little more flour.
DeleteThis recipe looks amazing! How long will it last in the fridge for?
ReplyDeleteThis is a good question! We've always eaten the recipe within 3-4 days so I am not sure how long it will really last. I'm guessing probably a week?
DeleteThank you! I hope you create a faux mozzarella. :)
ReplyDeleteI was wondering what makes this cheese melt, and as i read the comments, the full fat coconut milk, is that it. I have a recipe for vegan cheese, that firm, but does not melt, you recipe I did make not as firm as I like, but did melt, and my friends love the taste. I am going to make again and combine recipes. why do you want the vinegar to break down the agar, I am going to add onion pow and garlic salt cashews, miso and some lemon juice. So I can get the combination of melt and firm. thank you for a great recipe. And I want the cheese to come out yellow and not orange, is it the parika which gives it the orange color
ReplyDeleteCoconut milk does make the cheese melty!
DeleteI'd love to hear how the combined recipes turn out! That sounds delicious.
And yes, smoked paprika definitely gives this cheese the "color" (also the turmeric helps).
I love this recipe! Do you mind if I share it on my blog veganfoody.tumblr.com?
ReplyDeleteHi Tina,
DeleteWould love it if you shared my recipe. Please give credit where credit is due! Thank you and have a wonderful day!
Thanks! I just posted it this morning and Tumblr picked it as a featured post in the Food section. Great recipe.. thanks for letting me share it. :)
DeleteTrying this right now :). Wondering about the white balsamic. I am thinking about substituting ACV instead. I only have dark balsamic. This is great!
ReplyDelete